Online ordering powered by Seamless
151 Montague Street, (Montague St. Between Clinton St. & Henry St.)(718) 624-3838
Minimum order of $10.00 is required for delivery
Delivery estimate is 25-40 min (more info)
Seamless allows you to enjoy convenient online ordering from the best local restaurants. If you're ordering for the first time, start your order by entering your address to the right. Return users log in here.
Minimum order of $10.00 is required for delivery
Delivery estimate is 30 - 45 min (more info)
Print this menu
Served with dressing mixed in.
Served with choice of pasta and sauce.
Served with choice of pasta.
Choice of chicken or veal and pasta.
On the border between Manhattan’s Midtown and the Upper East Side, you will find a hidden treasure called Caffe Buon Gusto. It has a casual and comfortable dining room, but features like the unique décor and open windows in the summer set this Italian eatery apart from its competitors. Their traditional yet inventive menu boasts a variety of delicious favorites, and the warm bread to begin the meal lets customers know that they are in for something special.
The best part? Indulging in a night out at Caffe Buon Gusto won’t break your budget.
Crab Cakes—Over mixed greens in aioli dressing
Homemade Paglia e Fieno—Homemade green and white linguine with your choice of salmon or shrimp
Linguine Lobster—Linguine and diced lobster with pancetta in a carbonara cream sauce
Chicken Buon Gusto—Sautéed in marsala wine with Mozzarella, prosciutto and mushrooms
Veal Piccata—Sautéed in white wine and lemon
Eggplant Parmigiana—Sautéed with Mozzarella in tomato sauce
The food was good, the delivery was quick, and they even called to confirm my order. A+ customer service!
Posted a year ago by laura w.
Best dessert in the neighborhood hands down! Tried quite a few of them and have never been disappointed. If you're having a hard time choosing, go for the Tiramisu. Build your own pasta is a classic choice, the pesto and Alfredo sauces are good.
Posted a year ago by Bailey H.
Love the pasta here! Recently they also changed from smaller portions to a bigger portion container for when you order pasta as well! I ordered the Linguini with Carbonara sauce !! would recommend!
Posted a year ago by Chun L.
One of my favorites spots in BK - Delivery is quick and the quality is top notch!
Posted a year ago by olivia k.
Cafe Buon Gusto has my boyfriend's favorite fettuccine alfredo of everywhere we've tried. The side of pasta that comes with the entrees is not great; skip that and go for their homemade pasta, which is delicious.
Posted 2 years ago by Megan D.
I love this place and order from them constantly! they are fast and the food is consistent and good - love the squid ink pasta. a great value - they give you a huge piece of focaccia bread with each pasta and the "side" of pasta that comes with other dishes is huge.
Posted 2 years ago by Yee C.
Have to review given all the bad ones on here - I ordered at 9:45, homemade pasta w/ rabe & sausage, soup, salad. Food was here at 10:10. Pasta was hot and delicious. Mediterranean Salad was really exceptional, had like 10 different kinds of lettuce and veggies in it.
If there's any negative, portion sizes are probably small compared to the average italian restaurant. But pasta isnt supposed to be a multi-pound entree, it's supposed to be with soup and salad and etc. It was more than enough for one, and it was so good!
Posted 2 years ago by Charles D.
Shocking!! I ordered the Paglia e Fieno Salmon and didn't get salmon but some odd cubed skin-on white fish. Grossed me out ! No note explaining a shocking substitution. Very disappointed.
Posted 2 years ago by N N.
Its hard to really decide exactly what was wrong with the food. It just didnt taste right, not bad exactly just tasteless. We ordered a few times from this place and underwhelmed...
Posted 2 years ago by Iain M.
This place does basic Italian really well I've ordered a bunch of different items, homemade pasta with red and Alfredo sauces, chicken parm, even fish over spinach when I feel healthy, and I've always been happy. Fennel salad good too, chocolate almond cake is basically delicious fudge. Delivery is quick as well.
Posted 2 years ago by Sarah K.
I've had pleasant experiences with Cafe Buon Gusto. The food arrives promptly, is hot, well packaged, and is very good. I love all of their pasta dishes. Will order from them again.
Posted 2 years ago by Dorothy S.
The food took a while to get here, and when it did, ick. Chicken parm was kind of burnt and flavorless, as was the pasta accompanying the dish. Eggplant parm was bland as well. The spinach side had taste--garlic. Lots and lots of garlic. I feel like I just experienced a "before" meal at Restaurant: Impossible. Where's Robert Irvine when you need him?
Posted 2 years ago by Melissa K.
Great food and it was delivered hot!
Posted 2 years ago by elise b.
Soooo good. After our go-to Italian restaurant closed, we discovered Buon Gusto. Delicious food, fast service both in the restaurant and delivery at home. The linguini lobster (carbonera sauce) is our favorite, but anything you order is sure to be good.
Posted 2 years ago by Jennifer R.
Delivery was said to be between 30-45min. Ordered my food at 8:17PM and did not receive food until 10PM. Completely unacceptable! After an hour I called the restaurant, the manager said it was on its way, I call 30min after my original call and she says it's still on its way. I get there may be problems with delivery people, but no phone call to let me know if the problems is just awful customer service. And the food, was cold, not lukewarm, cold like it was sitting out for hours. And on top of that the desert was not included in my original order. All around awful experience. Originally the manager offered a free desert to make up for the trouble. Are you kidding me? Then it turned into 30% off my next order (why in the world would I ever order from you guys again). Lastly after enough complaining she offered a refund. Seriously that should have been the first option. I. WILL. NEVER. ORDER. FROM. HERE. AGAIN.
Posted 2 years ago by Jeff J.
We ordered 2 lunch Prix-Fixe meals.
Delivery was prompt and the food was hot.
Food quality was approaching awful. The Chicken Masala and Eggplant Parmesean tasted like cheap microwave meals; pasta sauce was bland; 'soup of the day' had very little flavor and felt like yesterday's kitchen leavings. "Garlic bread" was..ugh. Ceasar salad was ok. The Masala was the real low point- I love a good chicken masala, but this one was almost inedible. Funky mushrooms, weak sauce, soggy breading, bland chicken... No thanks.
The desserts were good! Cheese Cake and Almond Chocolate Cake were quite tasty.
Posted 2 years ago by Jude A.
Ordered through the restaurant week deal for me and 3 coworkers. The food that arrived was only so-so. They forgot 1 entree and 2 salads. Then they took over minutes to bring me replacement food (which one would think should just be cooked and ready, and even if not they're less than 5 blocks away). Once the replacement food did arrive, the salad looked like someone just took a limited fistful of lettuce and threw it into a tupperware and shook way too much cheese on top. One might think it's tough to screw up only 4 orders made through a delivery site (where it's all there in black and white) but they managed. Certainly won't be ordering from them when the whole department does lunch, and I won't be ordering from them when I do lunch again either.
Posted 2 years ago by Alex S.
Best Italian ever in the hood!!! Best is that you get to play and mix and match with pastas. I got the homemade ravioli and vodka sauce with mushrooms and sausage. Sooooo delicious. My boyfriend got the chicken Marsala and that was awesome. The grilled calamari was ok. Need extra sauce. The tomatoe mozzarella was great.
Posted 2 years ago by devin F.
It has always annoyed me that the photo this restaurant uses for Seamless shows seared tuna – an item you can not find on the menu. WTH? Why not show Kung Pao chicken too? One day I decided to search their menu for seared items and I landed on 2 (neither was tuna). So I gave the “Emiliano” a try with red snapper. While there was nothing “seared” about it, that was my one and only complaint. The fish portion was large, plump and moist. It was served over a moderate amount of sautéed spinach in a light tomato broth. Very Delicious and Healthy. A bit of a splurge for lunch at $19, but worth it with a referral coupon or on a 15% discount day ($16).
BTW - You have to actively click on the option to receive utensils. My delivery was quite fast. But I hit them before the big 1:00 rush.
Posted 2 years ago by Tanya R.
I love the Insalata All' Arancia, it is so fresh and refreshing with a great balance of flavors and textures. Plus the pasta is outstanding.
Posted 2 years ago by Sarah S.
The delivery was 20 minutes late. The food is cold. There are 13 pieces in this nearly $13 ravioli dish. That's a dollar a piece. what a rip off! That's insane. Also, they didn't include fork, knife, or napkin. never again.
Posted 3 years ago by Katy I.
This place is hit or miss. We tend to go with the same order every time, so it's really easy to compare the quality from one order to the next. Today we did something different and both decided to order the gnocchi fra diavolo. We knew it was a risk because if it sucked, BOTH of our meals would suck. But then if it was awesome, we'd wish we had two. Sadly it sucked. We actually ended up throwing it away, bye bye $20!
Posted 3 years ago by jill k.
I've enjoyed the food here for some years now, and tonight was the first time they ever sent over a faulty order.
I'm pleased to say that when I called them to get it corrected, I got a polite woman who told me they'd correct it and send it by ASAP, which is what happened. I appreciate that.
Posted 3 years ago by Miranda S.
This is the second time I've ordered from them and it is the same problem. Why am I paying for stuff and getting half of what i paid for. Also, dont get the panini's, their definition of panini i three small bite sized sandwiches and a bunch of salad to fill up the container. Thanks assholes.
Posted 3 years ago by Lan C.
I don't write reviews. Ever. But this warrants one... waited an hour for some simple desserts, which happened to be pre-packaged/cut in the first place. $6 each for something that doesn't even come close to 2 inches long, wide, or deep. Is this a joke? I'd love my money and/or tip back, what a waste. Steer clear.
Posted 3 years ago by Chris T.
Really good food. Arrived pretty quick as well. Be careful - portion is not too large, but definitely pretty filling for one meal!
Posted 3 years ago by Alice Z.
This place used to be amazing but something changed a few months ago, now every dish I get from here is mediocre. Not sure what happened, but have been burned one too many times to try them again. Unfortunate!
Posted 3 years ago by Anne K.
Delicious Caprese salad! I had the homemade ravioli with vodka sauce and it was really good. Not great, but really good. I'm picky about my Italian food as an Italian-American who cooks, and I'd order from here again, definitely, although I'd like to try something else on the menu because the vodka ravioli wasn't at the level of being a go-to dish for me.
Posted 4 years ago by Emily H.
DO NOT ORDER DESSERT FROM THESE PEOPLE. I ordered a piece of cheesecake ($5.95) and the most pathetic little piece of cake came. When I called the restaurant, the waiter who answered the phone was very rude. I could hear him cursing under his breath. I will never go to this restaurant again.
Posted 4 years ago by Evan G.
on time. very hot and delicious. i got pasta and it was enough to feed me for days. yummy!
Posted 4 years ago by Jaime C.
We have ordered from Buon Gusto several times now, and every time the food has been excellent! They are in the same price range as any higher-end Italian, but their quality makes it worth it. Handmade pastas are really good, and their focaccia is completely addictive! Delivery has been prompt and our orders are always correct as well.
Posted 4 years ago by Sharon E.
CBG offers standard food at a decent price. The service was on time (30-40 minutes) and the order accurate. I did not care for the bread--a crusty Italian, French, sourdough or peasant bread would have been better, and butter would have been nice. But I didn't order bread, I ordered Chicken Parm and Ziti and they were good. The Ziti was al dente and they did include a generous container of grated Parmesan cheese. As a single person I appreciate the low $10 minimum order amount.
Posted 4 years ago by Mitchell K.
Their homemade pasta is simple and excellent. Solid Italian comfort food.
Posted 5 years ago by Matthew H.
The BEST Italian restaurant in Brooklyn. Their Balsamic sauce is to die for.
Posted 5 years ago by Ed C.
Cafe Buon Gusto in Brooklyn is the best Italian restaurant I have ever been too. Their food is always fresh. They serve delicious ciabatta bread. My personal favorite is their homemade spinach ravioli with the marinara sauce. All their homemade pasta's are delicious and so are their sauces!! You must try everything on the menu! Their salads are amazing too. I would recommend the pear and gorgonzola salad. You must eat at this restaurant. You will regret it if you don't!
Posted 5 years ago by Khush K.
I was really disappointed with my order from Cafe Buon Gusto. My eggplant parmigiana was cold, and I think the eggplant had been grilled until it was burnt. The side of pasta was also cold and stuck together and not very appetizing to the eye or or the tastebuds. The only highlight of the meal was the iced tea, which arrived cold (noticing a trend?). I'm going to try to find another Italian delivery place near me because Cafe Buon Gusto was overall pretty terrible, unfortunately.
Posted 5 years ago by Jill F.
Great pasta and salads!
Posted 5 years ago by brittany n.
Really good alfredo sauce and homemade pastas
Posted 6 years ago by Erica B.
Food - high price but still excellent value for quality delivered. Usually accurate fullfillment., but sometimes omit plastic utensils.
Posted 6 years ago by David C.
I have only ever ordered pasta and mussels from here but I LOVE it! This is my favorite Italian food in the neightboorhood and they normally deliver their food within the expected time or earlier. The food is really good quality, the sauces are great and there are a nice variety of options.
Posted 7 years ago by Katie M.
Only select user reviews are published on Seamless. All user-submitted ratings contribute to Cafe Buon Gusto's overall Seamless rating, but we manually screen all reviews and only publish those that are relevant and helpful. Tips for getting your review published »
Above content provided by restaurant.
Order online from
Cafe Buon Gusto by entering your address
below. Online ordering powered by Seamless.com.
Return users log
Click a menu item to add it to your order.
Back to top
Seamless North America, LLC. All Rights Reserved.
0808 234 7862
Seamless North America, LLC. All Rights Reserved.